Writing Positive Masculinity
SPOILER ALERT
〰️
SPOILER ALERT 〰️
Positive portrayals of masculinity are a cornerstone of great storytelling, offering audiences role models who inspire and uplift without falling into toxic tropes. One of the most celebrated examples of positive masculinity in fiction is Aragorn, the noble ranger-turned-king from The Lord of the Rings. Aragorn’s strength, sensitivity, humility, and unwavering loyalty make him an enduring icon of what it means to be a true hero.
This article explores how Aragorn exemplifies positive masculinity, providing insights for writers looking to craft strong, honourable male characters. We’ll examine key scenes that highlight his heroic qualities, his relationships, and his balanced nature, demonstrating that masculinity can be powerful and tender without resorting to toxic or overly macho stereotypes.
Why Aragorn is a Positive Male Role Model
Aragorn is frequently cited as an ideal portrayal of masculinity for several reasons:
Strength Paired with Compassion: Aragorn is a formidable warrior, but his greatest strength lies in his ability to lead with empathy and humility. He doesn’t dominate; he inspires.
Emotional Depth: Aragorn is unafraid to show vulnerability, expressing love, grief, and doubt, which makes him relatable and human.
Loyalty and Honor: Aragorn’s unwavering loyalty to his companions and his sense of duty to Middle-earth are central to his character.
Respect for Others: Aragorn treats all people—regardless of their station—with dignity, earning their trust and respect through his actions rather than his lineage or power.
Balanced Heroism: He embodies the qualities of a classic action hero—bravery, skill in battle, and a commanding presence—without succumbing to arrogance or aggression.
Key Scenes Showcasing Aragorn’s Heroic Qualities
1. Aragorn’s Leadership at Helm’s Deep
In The Two Towers, Aragorn helps rally the people of Rohan at Helm’s Deep, despite their fear and despair. His speech to the young soldiers highlights his ability to lead through encouragement rather than intimidation, saying:
“Hold your ground, hold your ground! Sons of Gondor, of Rohan, my brothers! I see in your eyes the same fear that would take the heart of me. A day may come when the courage of men fails… but it is not this day!”
This scene exemplifies his strength as a leader who fights alongside his people, inspiring them to stand together. His courage is not for self-glory but to protect the vulnerable.
2. Sensitivity and Love for Arwen
Aragorn’s relationship with Arwen shows his capacity for deep love and devotion. He values her as his equal and is willing to sacrifice his own desires for her well-being. In The Two Towers, when he believes he might not return from battle, his thoughts turn to Arwen, and we see his emotional vulnerability. His willingness to let Arwen choose her own path underscores his respect for her autonomy. Their love is a partnership built on mutual respect and shared purpose.
3. Protecting Frodo
In The Fellowship of the Ring, Aragorn demonstrates his loyalty and selflessness when Frodo offers him the One Ring. Instead of succumbing to its power, Aragorn kneels and vows to protect Frodo, saying,
“I would have gone with you to the end, into the very fires of Mordor.”
This moment shows his resistance to temptation and his commitment to the greater good. His choice reflects his inner strength and his prioritization of Frodo’s mission over personal ambition.
4. Humility as a King
Aragorn’s coronation in The Return of the King is a masterclass in humility. When he is crowned king, he doesn’t revel in power or lord it over others. Instead, he kneels before the hobbits, acknowledging their contributions and expressing gratitude. This act of humility solidifies him as a leader who serves, rather than rules, his people.
Breaking the Toxic Masculinity Mold
Aragorn stands in stark contrast to toxic portrayals of masculinity that prioritize dominance, aggression, and emotional repression. Here’s how he defies these stereotypes:
He is Gentle Yet Strong: Aragorn’s kindness doesn’t undermine his strength. He is capable of great violence in battle, but he fights only when necessary, often as a protector.
He Values Collaboration: Aragorn doesn’t act as a lone wolf. He works alongside others—whether it’s Legolas, Gimli, or the hobbits—emphasizing the value of teamwork.
He Embraces Emotion: Aragorn is not afraid to show fear, sorrow, or love, demonstrating that vulnerability is not weakness but a mark of humanity.
He Respects Women: In his relationships with Arwen and Éowyn, Aragorn consistently shows respect, never treating them as damsels in distress or objects to be won.
Writing a Balanced Masculine Hero
Aragorn’s character provides a blueprint for writers aiming to create male protagonists who embody positive masculinity. Here are some key takeaways:
1. Combine Strength with Sensitivity
A strong male character doesn’t need to be stoic or emotionless. Show how his emotional depth complements his bravery. For example, a warrior can fight fiercely in battle but cry over the loss of a friend.
2. Focus on Leadership, Not Dominance
True leaders inspire and uplift those around them. Avoid writing characters who rely on intimidation or brute force to lead; instead, craft heroes who earn respect through their actions and values.
3. Highlight Healthy Relationships
Portray male characters who respect their partners and friends, value their opinions, and prioritize their well-being. Romantic subplots should reflect equality and partnership, not possessiveness or control.
4. Show Humility and Growth
Aragorn’s journey from a ranger reluctant to claim his throne to a confident king is a story of growth and self-acceptance. Let your characters struggle with doubts and fears—they’ll feel more human and relatable.
5. Embrace Teamwork
Avoid making your hero a lone saviour. Aragorn’s relationships with Legolas, Gimli, and the hobbits demonstrate that true strength comes from collaboration and mutual support.
Aragorn is a shining example of positive masculinity, combining strength, sensitivity, humility, and loyalty in a way that resonates with audiences. His heroic qualities remind writers that male characters don’t need to rely on toxic or hyper-macho traits to be compelling. Instead, they can be leaders who inspire, lovers who respect, and warriors who protect without aggression.
By following Aragorn’s example, writers can craft male protagonists who are not only powerful but also deeply human, creating heroes who truly stand the test of time.
